Sympathy or shock: How transgression diagnosticity impacts consumer perceptions and intentions regarding person-brands

No Thumbnail Available
Matthews, A. Lynn
Luebke, Sarah S.F.
Issue Date
Brand identification , Diagnosticity , Experimental design , Personal branding , Social identity theory , Transgression
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Matthews, A.L. and Luebke, S.S.F. (2023), "Sympathy or shock: how transgression diagnosticity impacts consumer perceptions and intentions regarding person-brands", Journal of Product & Brand Management, Vol. ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-print.

Purpose: Moral transgressions committed by person-brands can negatively impact consumers through the transgression's diagnosticity (severity, centrality and consistency). This paper aims to test how a transgression's centrality and consistency impact important consumer perceptions and behavioral intentions toward a person-brand, holding constant the transgression in question. These outcomes are crucial for person-brands to understand how to minimize and manage the impact of a given transgression. Design/methodology/approach: This paper uses three online consumer experiments to manipulate transgression diagnosticity via centrality and consistency and identifies the resulting impact on consumer-brand identification, trustworthiness and consumer digital engagement intentions through PROCESS models. Findings: High-diagnosticity transgressions lower consumer digital engagement intentions regarding the person-brand and their endorsed products. This effect is serially mediated by consumer-brand identification, as predicted by social identity theory, and by perceived trustworthiness of the person-brand. Practical implications: Person-brands should emphasize the nondiagnostic nature of any transgressions in which they are involved, including a lack of centrality and consistency with their brand, and guard against the appearance of diagnostic transgressions. Originality/value: This paper shows that transgression diagnosticity impacts consumer engagement through the pathway of consumer-brand identification and trustworthiness. It also manipulates aspects of diagnosticity that can be influenced by the person-brand (centrality and consistency) while holding the transgression constant. As such, this paper extends the literature on transgressions, on person-branding strategy, and on social identity theory.

Table of Contents
Click on the DOI link to access this article (may not be free).
Emerald Publishing
Book Title
Journal of Product and Brand Management
PubMed ID