Deeply disagreeing with myself: synchronic intrapersonal deep disagreements
Bondy, Patrick R.
MetadataShow full item record
Cite this article Bondy, P. Deeply Disagreeing with Myself: Synchronic Intrapersonal Deep Disagreements. Topoi (2020)
Interpersonal disagreement happens all the time. How to properly characterize interpersonal disagreement and how to respond to it are important problems, but the existence of such disagreements at least is obvious. The existence of intrapersonal disagreement, however, is another matter. On the one hand, we do change our minds sometimes, especially when new evidence comes in, and so there is a clear enough sense in which we can be characterized as having disagreements with our past selves. But what about synchronic disagreements with ourselves? Are such cases possible, or is there something about the nature of belief that rules out the possibility of knowingly holding beliefs which cannot be rationally held at the same time? In this paper, I argue that there can be cases of intrapersonal synchronic disagreement, and that such disagreements can be deep, in the same way that interpersonal disagreements can be deep. For intrapersonal disagreements, just like interpersonal disagreements, can be grounded in conflicting frameworks for interpreting and reasoning about the world. I also argue that synchronic intrapersonal disagreements are peer disagreements. The paper ends with a discussion of four possible responses to interpersonal deep disagreements, concluding that if those responses are sometimes rational responses in the interpersonal case, then they are also sometimes rational responses in the intrapersonal case.
Click on the DOI link to access the article (may not be free).
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Team combat identification: effects of gender, spatial visualization, and disagreement Baker, Anthony L.; Keebler, Joseph R.; Anania, Emily C.; Schuster, David; Plummer, John P. (SAGE, 2020-02-04)Objective: The combat identification (CID) abilities of same-gender and mixed-gender dyads were experimentally assessed, along with measures of spatial skills and team communication. Background: CID is a high-stakes ...
Disagreeing in bogota YouTubers' sites: A playful display of identities and solidarity through the use of disagreement Sierra, Jennifer (Wichita State University. Department of Anthropology, 2016)As Social Media continues to transform and expand contemporary linguistic landscapes, this paper intends to add to the analyses of the new communicative practices taking place in these sites. Even though social media has ...
Introduction: Disagreement—epistemological and argumentation-theoretic perspectives Bondy, Patrick R.; Godden, David (Springer, 2021-10-11)