Mathematical structuralism, modal nominalism, and the coherence principle
Schwartz, James S. J.
MetadataShow full item record
James S.J. Schwartz Mathematical Structuralism, Modal Nominalism, and the Coherence Principle Philosophia Mathematica (2015) 23 (3): 367-385
According to Stewart Shapiro's coherence principle, structures exist whenever they can be coherently described. I argue that Shapiro's attempts to justify this principle (along with his position, ante rem structuralism) are circular, as he relies on criticisms of modal nominalism which presuppose the coherence principle. I argue further that when the coherence principle is not presupposed, his reasoning more strongly supports modal nominalism than ante rem structuralism.
Click on the DOI link to access the article (may not be free).